Do Older Scanned Records Belong in Your Recording or Case Management System?

In short

  • Older scanned records don't always need to be imported into your recording system, case management system, or other main records software. Collections people rarely pull can live in a separate home that keeps them searchable and safe.
  • That main system is built for the records your office works in every day, and loading older collections into it can carry an import fee.
  • We know a separate home can look like another information silo, and keeping records together is usually the right call, but for older collections people rarely open, it pays to do the math.
  • Asking how often staff pull a collection, and who needs to search it, usually shows whether it belongs in the main system or beside it.
  • Cyclone, RDS's digital preservation platform, gives older collections a searchable home beside the system you run your office on, and the records can move into that system later. The question usually comes up partway through a scanning project. The pages are captured, the indexing is underway, and someone asks where the records should live. Clerks, recorders, registers, court clerks, city and town clerks, and IT directors all face it, whether the office runs a recording system, a case management system, or other records software. In this article, we call that your main system.

Older collections that someone pulls a few times a year need to be searchable and easy for staff to reach, at a cost that makes sense for how often they're used.

Isn't a separate home just another information silo?

It's a fair question, and IT departments and software providers are right to ask it. Records spread across too many places are hard to find, hard to manage, and easy to lose track of. Most of the time, keeping records in one system is the better path.

But sometimes you have to do the math. When an import would cost more than a rarely used collection will ever return, that money may do more good going into scanning. A separate home only makes sense if it's one place, searchable and protected, not another drive in a drawer. And it shouldn't be a dead end. Records in Cyclone aren't locked in, and they can move into the main system when the time is right.

What we hear in the office

Here's what we hear that tells us a collection may need a home of its own.

"What will it cost to import these?"

Software providers charge to load data into their systems, and for active records that's part of doing business. For older collections, the math can change.

One IT director we work with was planning a project to scan older probate records. Before deciding where the records would go, the office asked its software provider for an import quote. It came back at about $32,000. The office decided to put those records in a separate, searchable home and spend the money on scanning more of the collection instead. The office's goal was to go deeper into the records, and the import fee was standing in the way.

"It's in books, spreadsheets, hard drives, and some of it is in our system"

Meeting minutes are one example we've seen. Over the years, one collection ends up in four places, and nobody can see all of it at once.

Zane Foster, an RDS account manager in Texas, met a clerk with her minutes in all four. "We have the ability to bring all these disparate data sources into one area," he says, so she can "see her collection fully on one system." Once it's together, the office can decide whether to index it further.

"Nobody ever pulls those, but we have to keep them"

Some collections are required to be kept and almost never requested. A large microfilm collection is a good example. The cost of loading it into the main system is hard to justify. A simple, searchable copy on a workstation in the office can serve the few people who need it.

"Our deputies end up helping people find them"

This one shows up when older files were delivered on thumb drives and copied onto a shared drive at a public terminal. If the files are named only by case number, a researcher has to look up the number in the images of the old index books, then go find the file.

Kevin Grogan, also an RDS account manager in Texas, heard it from a district clerk recently. "The clerk told me that more times than not, her deputies have to come over to the terminal and help somebody." Records that are indexed and searchable in one place let researchers find what they need on their own, and let deputies get back to the counter.

"We're still waiting to load it"

A long scanning project can run for years. Loading each finished set can mean paying for an import every time, and large loads take time. Meanwhile, staff can't use the scanned records.

Keeping the records searchable while the work continues solves both. Staff use the records now, and the office can review, correct, and validate the indexing as it goes. When the full project is done, the collection can be loaded into the main system once.

"We'll just put them on the network"

Asked how they want scans delivered, offices often say this, or a hard drive, or a shared folder in Google Drive. It works until someone needs a specific record. A folder of files has no index to search and no plan for keeping the records safe over time.

Questions to ask before you import older records

Before you pay to load a historical collection, answer these:

  • How often do staff actually pull these records?
  • Will you keep adding to this collection, or is it closed?
  • Is the goal to preserve the records, or will staff work in them every week?
  • Does anyone outside the office need to search them directly?
  • What does the import quote cover, and what would that money do if it went into scanning instead? If the answers point to a closed collection that's used now and then, the main system may not be the right place for it. If the records are part of the office's active, day-to-day work, the main system is often the better home.

Where Cyclone fits

Cyclone is RDS's digital preservation platform. It doesn't replace the recording, case management, or enterprise system you run your office on. It gives older collections a protected, searchable home beside it, sized to how the records are actually used, or a place to review indexing before an import.

The question isn't whether Cyclone has every feature of a full enterprise platform. The question is whether you need a full enterprise platform for these records.

  • Cyclone Vault: a protected, searchable home for records you pull occasionally.
  • Cyclone Core: a workspace for staff who search, organize, and work with historical records regularly.
  • Cyclone Public: read-only public search of the Core collections you choose to share. It adds on to Core.
  • Cyclone Certify: a place to review and approve indexed land records and images before they're imported into your recording system. Cyclone can be as simple as a kiosk-style workstation in the office where the public can look up certain records, or a place staff use for internal documents.

Current pricing for each product is on the Cyclone page.

Start where you are

Every office is at a different place. We figure out where you are, join you there, and work out where to start with the budget you have.

RDS scans, indexes to your office's own rules, and delivers the records wherever they'll do the most good: your main system, Cyclone, or each in turn. RDS has worked with 790 government entities in 38 states.

Frequently asked questions

Do our older scanned records have to be loaded into our recording or case management system?

No, not always. Active records belong in the system your office works in every day. Older, closed collections that are rarely requested can often live in a separate, searchable home instead, which can save the cost of an import and leave more of the budget for scanning.

What is Cyclone?

Cyclone is the digital preservation platform from Revolution Data Systems (RDS). It gives older public records a protected, searchable home beside an office's main recording or case management system. It comes in four products: Vault, Core, Public, and Certify, each matched to how the records will be used.

How much does Cyclone cost?

Cyclone is sold as an annual subscription, and each of its four products is priced separately. Current pricing is listed on the Cyclone page at revolutiondatasystems.com/cyclone. The right product depends on how often staff pull the records and whether the public needs to search them.

Does Cyclone replace our recording or case management system?

No. Cyclone sits beside the system you run your office on. Active records stay in your main system, and Cyclone gives older or rarely used collections a searchable home of their own, so you don't have to load everything into a system built for daily work.

Can the public search records in Cyclone?

Yes, with Cyclone Public, which is an add-on to Cyclone Core. Your staff choose which collections to share, and public search is read-only. That lets researchers look up those records on their own without your staff pulling them for each request.

If we put records in Cyclone, can we move them into our main system later?

Yes. Records in Cyclone aren't locked in, and they can be moved into your main system when you're ready. Some offices may want a searchable home for records during a long scanning project, then load the full collection into the main system once the project is complete.

Talk with us about your records

If you're weighing an import quote, or a collection is scattered across drives and shelves, tell us what you have and how people use it. We'll help you think through where it should live. Contact RDS.